Cement board is not typically recommended as an underlayment for pavers due to structural incompatibility and installation challenges. While cement board is moisture-resistant and durable, it lacks the necessary load-bearing capacity and flexibility required for paver installations. A proper paver base usually consists of compacted sand or gravel, which allows for drainage and accommodates the natural expansion and contraction of pavers. This article explores the limitations of using cement board for pavers and suggests more suitable alternatives.
Why is Cement Board Not Suitable for Paver Underlayment?
Cement board, while versatile in many construction applications, is not designed to serve as an underlayment for pavers. Here are the key reasons:
-
Insufficient Load-Bearing Capacity: Cement boards are typically rated for loads up to 60 psf in wall and floor applications. However, paver installations, especially those subject to vehicle traffic or heavy foot traffic, require a much higher load-bearing capacity.
-
Lack of Flexibility: Pavers need a base that allows for slight movement and settling. Cement board is rigid and doesn’t provide the necessary flexibility.
-
Drainage Issues: Unlike a sand or gravel base, cement board doesn’t allow for proper water drainage, which is crucial for the longevity of paver installations.
-
Installation Complexity: Adapting cement board for use under pavers would require unconventional and potentially problematic installation methods.
What Are the Weight-Bearing Limitations of Cement Board?
Cement board has specific weight limitations that make it unsuitable for paver installations:
- The maximum installed weight of the finish system on cement board should not exceed 15 psf.
- USG Durock® cement board, for example, is designed for uniform loads up to 60 psf in wall and floor applications.
These capacities are insufficient for most paver installations, especially those in high-traffic areas or driveways.
What Are the Recommended Underlayment Options for Pavers?
Instead of cement board, consider these proven underlayment options for pavers:
- Sand or Gravel Base:
- Most common and recommended option
- Provides stability and allows for drainage
-
Accommodates paver expansion and contraction
-
Compacted Soil:
- Suitable for some installations
- Requires proper preparation and leveling
- May not offer the same drainage benefits as sand or gravel
Here’s a comparison of these options:
| Underlayment | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Sand/Gravel Base | – Excellent drainage – Flexible – Stable |
– Requires more material – More labor-intensive |
| Compacted Soil | – Cost-effective – Suitable for some applications |
– Less drainage – Potential for settling |
| Cement Board | – Moisture-resistant – Durable |
– Not suitable for pavers – Lacks flexibility – Poor drainage |
How Do You Properly Install a Sand or Gravel Base for Pavers?
To install a proper sand or gravel base for pavers, follow these steps:
- Excavate the area to the required depth (typically 4-6 inches for pedestrian areas, 6-8 inches for driveways).
- Add a layer of geotextile fabric to prevent soil mixing with the base material.
- Add a layer of gravel or crushed stone and compact it thoroughly.
- Spread a layer of coarse sand (about 1 inch thick) and level it using screeding boards.
- Lay the pavers on the prepared base.
- Fill joints with fine sand and compact the pavers.
What Are the Moisture-Related Concerns with Paver Underlayment?
Proper moisture management is crucial for paver longevity:
- Drainage: The underlayment must allow water to drain away from the pavers to prevent pooling and potential damage.
- Frost Heave: In cold climates, a proper base helps mitigate the effects of frost heave, which can cause pavers to shift or crack.
- Efflorescence: Good drainage helps reduce the likelihood of efflorescence, a white, powdery deposit that can form on pavers due to moisture.
While cement board is moisture-resistant, it doesn’t address these specific paver-related moisture concerns as effectively as a properly installed sand or gravel base.
What Are the Cost Implications of Different Paver Underlayment Options?
The choice of underlayment can significantly impact the overall cost of your paver project:
- Sand/Gravel Base: Generally more cost-effective in the long run due to better performance and longevity.
- Compacted Soil: Potentially the least expensive option, but may lead to higher maintenance costs over time.
- Cement Board: While the material itself isn’t overly expensive, the additional labor and materials required to adapt it for paver use would likely increase costs unnecessarily.
Consider these factors when budgeting for your paver project:
- Material costs
- Labor for preparation and installation
- Long-term maintenance requirements
- Potential for repairs or replacement
How Does Underlayment Choice Affect Paver Stability and Longevity?
The choice of underlayment plays a crucial role in the stability and longevity of your paver installation:
- Sand/Gravel Base:
- Provides excellent stability
- Allows for natural settling without compromising the surface
-
Enhances drainage, reducing the risk of frost heave and erosion
-
Compacted Soil:
- Can be stable if properly prepared
- May be more susceptible to settling and erosion over time
-
Less ideal for areas with poor drainage or freeze-thaw cycles
-
Cement Board (not recommended):
- Lacks the flexibility to accommodate natural ground movement
- Doesn’t provide adequate drainage
- May lead to cracking or shifting of pavers
For optimal paver stability and longevity, a properly installed sand or gravel base is the most reliable choice.
In conclusion, while cement board is a valuable material in many construction applications, it is not suitable as an underlayment for pavers. The structural requirements, drainage needs, and installation methods for pavers are best met by traditional sand or gravel bases. These options provide the necessary stability, flexibility, and drainage to ensure a long-lasting and attractive paver installation.